Open DBS Treasures Account
With more individuals now preferring to invest in the market for wealth creation one of the first steps when considering your investment plan is to compare SIP vs Lumpsum approaches. While a SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) offers accessibility with smaller contributions, a lump sum offers a way to invest if you want to park a significant amount in an investment instrument. In this article we will explore the difference between the SIP and Lump-sum investment approaches.
A Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) is a strategy that allows investors to put in a fixed sum at regular intervals, usually every month or quarter. This investment method promotes wealth creation through consistent long-term investment so that returns are less affected by short-term market conditions.
For example, you decide to invest INR 5,000 each month through an SIP. With the benefit of rupee cost averaging and disciplined approach you can easily build a strong financial foundation with good returns.
Whether you are beginning to invest or have experience in investing, SIPs offer several benefits to make it a preferred way to invest in mutual funds:
SIP investing offers various options to suit different investor needs and preferences such as:
DBS Treasures’ Mutual Fund Portfolio allows you to build a diversified portfolio across equity, debt, balanced, and liquid funds—tailored to your goals and risk appetite.
Lump-sum investment involves putting a large amount of money into the market in a single transaction. It's a suitable option if you have extra funds from a bonus, inheritance, or selling an asset. This method offers instant exposure to market movements, but returns can vary based on market timing and how well short-term fluctuations are managed.
If you are wondering SIP or lump-sum, which is better for you, it’s important to understand how both investment methods function, here’s a quick comparison of SIP vs lump sum investment.
Factor
SIP (Systematic Investment Plan)
Lumpsum Investment
Investment Style
Invests small, fixed amounts at regular intervals
Invests the entire amount in one go
Payment Frequency
Weekly, monthly, or quarterly
One-time payment
Market Timing Need
Not required – benefits from rupee cost averaging
Critical – timing significantly impacts returns
Risk Exposure
Lower – distributes risk over time
Higher – entire capital exposed to market at once
Ideal For
Salaried individuals, new investors
Investors with surplus funds, experienced market participants
Discipline Factor
Encourages regular saving habit through automation
Requires mental discipline to stay invested during volatility
Return Potential
Moderate, risk-adjusted over long term
Potentially higher if invested during market lows
Flexibility
High – can pause, modify, or stop investments
Limited – less flexibility after investing
When selecting between SIP vs lump sum investment, it is important to factor in how each investment method performs under a volatile market state.
SIPs have lower exposure to risk as its investments are spread across time, since the investments are automated it keeps investors consistent through any market downturns.
Lumpsum investments on the other hand are exposed to market timing risk, which means an investment can underperform if mistimed.
SIPs are often better suited for beginners and risk-averse investors, offering steady contributions and long-term growth potential. Those with extra funds might opt for a hybrid strategy by continuing with SIPs while making lump sum investments during major market corrections.
Both investment methods are taxed differently and can affect your actual returns when comparing SIP vs lump sum. Here’s an illustrative example to show how taxation works for both investment types:
Aspect
SIP Investment
Capital Gains Tax
Each SIP installment is treated as a separate investment.
Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG)
15% tax on gains if units are sold within 12 months of that SIP date.
Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG)
10% tax on gains above INR 1 lakh if held for more than 12 months.
Tax Holding Period
Calculated per SIP date. For example, SIP made on 1 Jan 2024 will qualify for LTCG only after 1 Jan 2025.
Tax Planning Tip
Use a systematic withdrawal strategy to minimise STCG liability.
Lump Sum Investment
One-time investment has a single purchase date.
15% tax on gains if sold within 12 months of investment date.
Starts from the lump sum investment date.
If nearing 1 year, consider delaying withdrawal to benefit from LTCG rates.
Choose SIP for better utilization of annual LTCG exemption limits and take advantage of staggered capital gains. However, if you want to make qualify for long-term taxation benefits and want to keep record keeping simple you can consider lump-sum investment.
As an investor if you want to figure out which is better SIP or lump sum consider these factors:
With a DBS Treasures wealth account, you get access to your own Relationship Manager and exclusive wealth solutions. These are available once you meet a minimum Total Relationship Value (TRV) and help guide your investment choices.
When deciding between SIP vs lumpsum, which is better depends on your financial situation, risk tolerance, and investment goals. SIP offers accessibility, rupee cost averaging, and reduced volatility risk, making it ideal for beginners and regular income earners. Lumpsum provides immediate market exposure and higher return potential for experienced investors with surplus funds. Consider a hybrid approach combining both strategies to maximize wealth creation opportunities across different market cycles.
